An actionable, bullet points summary for one of my favorite, all time best-seller and trading bible: Hedge Fund Market Wizards book, released in 2012.
Part 1 - Macro Men
C1 - Colm O'Shea: knowing when it's raining
- he does not forecast what will happen but recognize what has happened
- very difficult to pick tops/bottoms, better wait for confirmation events like the drying up liquidity in money market in Aug 2007
- trade implementation is more important than trade idea itself
- 2007: yield curve spread (long short-term rate/short long-term rate) instead of long/short rate instruments
- NASDAQ peak: long bond (economic slow down, lower interest rates) instead of short position in stocks (very likely to be stopped out on a 40% re-bounce)
- flexibility is important quality in trading - be ready to get out of a trade if price action is inconsistent with the hypothesis
- Apr 2009 was pessimistic about market outlook but price action was telling the opposite and market started a Asia-led multi-year rally
-
trade long side of a bubble
- get in early
-
limit the downside in worst case scenario because bubble burst are sharp
- low volatility bubble markets are implemented with long calls instead of long outright positions
-
sometimes there is no fundamental reason for the trade but price action can reveal important things like:
- magnitude of the move
- invest first, investigate later - G. Soros
- decide at what price your initial hypothesis is wrong and set the stop loss there
- right skewed trades, maximum loss is constrained, win is unlimited
C2 - Ray Dalio: the man who loves mistakes *
- fundamental systematic computer model, both alpha and beta funds
- alpha is skill/volatility, beta is directional with benchmark index
- timeless and universal approach
-
2 key factors:
- growth
- inflation
-
2 states:
- increasing
- decreasing
-
4 market conditions:
- growth increasing
- growth decreasing
- inflation increasing
- inflation decreasing
-
split world into 2 types of countries:
- creditors
- debtors
-
2 characteristics:
- countries that can exercise independent monetary policies
- those that can't
-
4 classifications of countries:
- debtors countries with independent monetary policies - e.g. US, UK
- debtors without independent policies - e.g. Greece, Portugal
- creditor countries with independent monetary policies - e.g. Brazil
- creditors without independent policies - e.g. China (Yuan is pegged to USD)
-
from Principles book:
- recognize that mistake if it results in learning
- create a culture where is OK to fail but unacceptable to not analyze and learn from mistake
- bring mistake in the open and analyze objectively
- treat mistakes as learning opportunities
- radical transparency, openness and honesty
- never say anything to a person that can't say it directly
- diversification is the holy grail of investing
- correlation can be misleading statistics - highly variable and prevailing circumstances
- gold and bonds are inverse correlated but in deleveraging cycle they are correlated because of monetary easing that decreases interest rates
- focus on underlying drivers that are expected to effect the positions; drivers are the cause, correlation is the effect
- forward looking approach, based on drivers: anticipate when gold and bonds are likely to move in the same direction
- backward looking: based on correlation
- different positions have different drivers
- markets behave differently in deleveraging and recession environments
- government actions that might lead to sustained rebound in recession have little effect in deleveraging
- U.S. out of gold standard and Mexico default followed by a huge market rally
- mistake provide the path to improvement and ultimate success
- write down mistake and learn from it
-
template for understanding economy as 3 acting forces:
- productivity growth
-
long term credit expansion/deleveraging cycle
- debt payments become larger that amount we can borrow and spending must decline
- when it can't raise more credit then process reverses and we have deleveraging
- money coming into debtors hands is not enough to meet obligations then assets need to be sold and spending cut to raise cash
- this leads to assets value fall, which reduces the value of collateral and in turn reduces incomes
- because both lower collateral and lower income reduces credit worthiness is reduced and they can't get enough credit
- and it continues in self reinforcing manner
- deleveraging is different from recession
- unlike in recession when cutting rates to raise money can fix the problems, in deleveraging monetary policy is ineffective
-
in recession interest rates can be cut to:
- ease debts
- stimulate economic activity
- produce a positive wealth effect
- in deleveraging interest rates are already 0% and cant be lowered and
- credit growth is difficult because borrowers remain indebted
- in inflationary deleveraging monetary policy is ineffective because increased money goes into other currencies and inflation-hedge assets are inflated
- business cycle - fluctuations in economic activities
-
really big pictures (centuries time frame):
- countries are poor and they think they are poor
- countries getting rich quickly but they still think they are poor
- countries are are rich and think of themselves as rich
-
countries become poorer and still think of themselves as rich - leveraging up phase, the debt rises relative to income until they cant;
- spending is still strong and they appear rich while balance sheet deteriorate
- twin deficits: both balance of payments and government deficits
- accumulation of debt that cant be paid back in non-depreciating money which leads to next stage
-
countries goes thru deleveraging and relative decline which are slow to accept
- after bubbles burst, deleveraging occur, private debt growth and private sector spending, asset value and net-worth declines in self reinforcing manner
- to compensate gov debt growth, gov deficits and central banks printing of money increase
- these countries have to compete with less expensive countries that are in earlier stages
- currencies depreciating and power in the world declines
C3 - Larry Benedict: beyond tree strikes *
- the road to success is often paved with mistakes
- mean reversion trader: seller in the short-term up swings and buyer in short term declines
- entry level determined by the volatility and bias
- long / short in different markets
- very good Sharpe and gain to pain ratio
- cuts the trading size in half after 2% loss, liquidate portfolio and start clean
-
3 type of trading styles:
- fundamental traders say that will buy this stock for the next 6 months
- technical traders say that if stock goes to this level will sell or buy if goes to different level
- Larry lets the market speak to him to buy or sell
- technical discretionary trader that does not use charts
- he looks at market in contrast with other markets: correlation come and go
- discretionary process starting with inter-market correlation
-
2 keys points:
- limits portfolio risk to 2.5%
- when the draw-down is reached he reduces the size until he is profitable again
- you are not a trader, you are a risk manager
- never stay in losing trades, don't freeze, you need to know how to respond in each situation
C4 - Scott Ramsey: low-risk futures trader
- discretionary trader in highly liquid futures in FX markets
- broad fundamental macro view and direction bias in each market and goes short the weakest market if bearish and long the strongest market if bullish
- in futures the only meaning full metric is return/risk
- identify big picture fundamental factors to derive the market and use technical to trade in that direction
- fundamentals as contrarian indicator - bearish fundamental has bullish price action because it was not effective
- buy the strongest, sell the weakest, novice traders do the opposite
- price movement in related markets can reveal one strength of weakness
- 0.1% on each trade from the point of entry and allows for more risk if ahead on the trade
C5 - Jaffray Woodriff: the third way *
-
he wanted 3 things:
- to be a trader
- to use computerize approach
- to do it differently than anyone else
-
3 types of systems:
- trend following
- counter trend (mean reversion)
- patterns of higher/lower prices
-
4 rules:
- is possible to find systems (that are neither trend-following nor mean-reversal) and work better than the standard systems
- it possible to data mine and search for patters without falling victim to curve fitting
- all price data (30 years old) can be as meaningful as recent data
- systems that work in multiple markets are better than systems that work in specific markets
- change position size according to volatility
- as all successful traders he found a method that suits him
- was very good recognizing systems that do not match his personality even after 3 days of testing
Part 2 - Multi-strategy players
C6 - Edward Thorpe: the innovator *
- can the market be beat?
- if you have enough monkeys that hit keys they will ultimately write Shakespeare
- the problem is that you need a lot of monkey that can't fit into visible universe
- track record (227 winning months out of 230) or 227 heads in 230 coin tosses with a probability of 1 in 10^63
-
2 ways of looking at his record:
- he was unbelievably lucky
- efficient market hypothesis is wrong
-
a lot of first-time achievements:
- wearable computer to win at roulette
- blackjack winning strategy
- systematic approach to trade warrants (long-term options) and convertible securities (options, convertible bonds, preferred stocks)
- formulate options pricing model equivalent of Black-Scholes model
- founder of the first market neutral fund
- quant hedge fund
- convertible arbitrage
- statistical arbitrage
- likely the first to uncover that Bernie Maddoff was a fraud
- his sister said that "do what you love and money will follow"
- 44% edge in roulette by predicting the ending zone
- vary the bet size to improve the odds in classic blackjack strategy
- trade smaller (or not at all) for lower probability trades and larger for high probability ones
- quantitative traders: statistical analysis of past results
- discretionary traders: confidence levels in different trades acts as probability
- exposure reduction on draw-downs in directional trades in contrast to arbitrage trades where edge can be easily calculated
- don't bet more than you are comfortable with, betting $1 on bad hands and $10 on good hands in Blackjack
- emotions are deadly when trading beyond comfort level
- there is no single winning solution and existing edges are continuously changing
- starting with hedging long positions in stocks that got down the most with short positions in stocks that got up the most - delta neutral
- then added market/ sector neutrality
- Kelly criterion for calculation the optimal size for each trade
- Kelly criterion assume the probability of winning and win/loss ratio are precisely known in advance (like in gambling but not in trading)
C7 - Jamie Mai: seeking asymmetry *
- profiled in the book The Big Short by Michael Lewis
- profit of 80x the premium paid on betting on sub-prime mortgages in 2008 crisis
- implementing structured highly asymmetric positive skew trades, long shots where profit is far larger than loss
- Sharpe ratio is a volatility (standard deviation) measure (calculated as (return - free rate risk) / volatility) which will penalty win spikes
- gain to pain ratio (return/risk) is a measure of loss (rather than volatility)
-
5 main pillars:
- find mis-priced options in theoretical priced world
- select trades with a positively skewed outcome, probability weighed gain must be upside of probability weighed loss
- implement trades asymmetrically - buy mis-priced options
- wait for high conviction trades
- use cash to target portfolio risk - 50% to 80% in cash
- options are priced by using certain assumptions that sometimes are not aligned with prevailing fundamentals
-
5 generally accepted assumptions that sometimes might be invalid:
- prices are normally distributed
- the forward price is perfect predictor of the future mean
-
volatility scales with the square root of time - this might understate potential volatility because:
- the longer the time period the more likely volatility will revert to the mean from current levels
- longer periods allow for more opportunity for trends to result in larger price moves that the one implied by the volatility
- the trend can be ignored in the volatility calculation
- current correlations are good prediction for future correlations
- risk != volatility
- good traders get out of positions when they realize the assumption was wrong
- great traders take the opposite trade
C8 - Michael Platt: the art and science of risk control
-
two biggest mistakes in trading:
- not enough homework
- they are bit too casual about risk
- he is a master of risk control
- risk management begins with trade implementation: long options or spread structures instead of outright long/short positions
- close a trade if it does not work within a reasonable amount of time
- extremely tight range of what a rookie trader can loose: 3% loss triggers a 50% reduction in allocation
- large percentage loses require increasingly percentage gains to get back to even
- losing trades makes you feel like an idiot and you are not in the mood to put anything on
- 80/20 rule: 80% of the profit comes from 20% of the trades
- attention to how market react to news as confirmation of his trading ideas
-
uses a systematic trend-following strategy:
- system will liquidate positions when trend is over-extended while waiting for reversal signals
- continuous improvements, system trading is a dynamic process, "a research war"
Part 3 - Equity traders
C9 - Steve Clark: do more of what works and less of what doesn't
- poor guy living in outskirts of London
-
a lots of traders deviate from what they do best
- good long term traders take short term positions with no edge
- other traders have effective systems but get bored and overwrite it with discretionary decisions
- find what you are best in and focus on that - analyze past trades
- entry size is more important than entry price - you wake up thinking about it
- trade within your emotional capacity
- in 2007 he reduces the trading size by 75% in response to increased volatility
- good traders can change their mind in a minute if price action is inconsistent with their hypothesis
- when trading badly, get out of everything and go in vacation, regain objectivity
- you can't be objective if you are in the market, taking physical break will stop downward spiral
- be aware of trades born of euphoria
- staring at the screen all day is counter-productive
- the job of a trader is to protect the equity line
C10 - Martin Taylor: the tzar has no clothes
- decreased AUM to 1/4 of original amount
-
3 characteristics:
-
favorable macro outlook, 2 keys ways:
- concentrate longs in countries with positive fundamentals
- global macro outlook can influence net portfolio exposure
- supportive very long-term trend
- good company - growth, value priced at its future prospects
-
- sometimes is better to be in the market with modest exposure than be outside of the market and chase the whipsaw moves to get in
- need to know your modest net exposure
- obsession for monthly returns can adversely influence long term investments
- during the bubble the most profitable are imprudent traders, not the skilled ones
C11 - Tom Claugus: a change of plans
- vary net exposure based on opportunity within the 95% price band of all the price observations
- when price is near the lower band, he will hold max long and the opposite when touching upper band
- looking for company that benefit from future plans that are not being priced-in: new tech, new sources of prod, increase assets
- if revenue source is more than 2 years in the future the market will fail to assign significant value to it
- fundamental screens fail to identify these because the source of bullish potential is not reflected in current statistics
- shorting stocks at the end of 1999
- as long as a profitable strategy is implemented, a loss is not a trading mistake
- also a winning trade might be a poor trading decision
- trading is a matter of probabilities and any strategy will be wrong a certain % of the trades
- a good trade can loose money, a bad trade can make money
- a good trade follows a process that will be profitable if repeated multiple times even if it can loose money in individual trades
- a bad trade follows a process that loose money if repeated multiple times but might make money on individual trades
- an analogy: a slot machine is a bad bet because has a higher probability of losing money if repeated multiple times
C12 - Joe Vidich: harvesting losses
- the author found Joe in a hedge fund database, not recommented like the most of the market wizards
- don't try to be 100% right: taking partial loss instead of all or nothing
- limit your position size in such a way that fear does not become the prevailing instinct guiding your judgment
- long time bull but also took short side once in a while
- don't make trading decision based on where you bought or sold
- get used to frustrating experiences when market turns around after you closed the position
C13 - Kevin Daly: who is Warren Buffet?
- he looked up who is Warren Buffet during his job interview and follows Warren's investment philosophy
- mostly long only fund and cash from time to time
- superior stocks selection was main strategy, not participating in the bear market
- importance of patience when environment is adverse to your approach, or opportunities are lacking
- largely in cash during 2000 - 2002 bear market
-
investment rules:
- find companies you understand
- take profits when they reach valuation levels
- sail into a cash harbor when market is stormy
- stick to the basic process
- treat investment as a business, not as a gamble
- stick to business you understand
- small assets size ($50M) investing in small cap stocks, move in and out of positions
C14 - Jimmy Balodimas: stepping in front of freight trains *
- he breaks all the rules, adds to looses and cuts the profits short
- mostly short in a up-trend market
- no emotions regardless he is up or down for the day or month
- don't try this at home
-
3 lessons with general applicability:
- the need to adapt to continuously changing market conditions
-
trading around the positions
- if he is short will reduce the position on price breaks and rebuild the positions on rally
- avoid euphoria - parabolic move
- if you are long in a market that you are afraid to sell, it might not be a bad idea to reduce your position
- very skilled in identifying turning points before they happen
- even the best traders might not execute their strategies the best way
- proficiency is achievable with hard work but performing at an elite level requires some degree of innate talent
- he found an approach that fits his personality: independent, competitive, contrarian, comfortable with risk
- the same approach might be disastrous for most other traders
- you cannot succeed in the market by copying someone else approach
C15 - Joel Greenblatt: the magic formula
- investing strategy inspired from Warren Buffet
- he believes in efficient market theory that stocks will ultimately trade at fair value
- but price can deviate substantially from their fair value for long periods, even years
- you don't have to trade all the time, wait for right strike
- past performance to select managers
- stock indexes are better investments than hedge funds because of less fees
- options are based on mathematical formulas and might provide great risk/reward trades
Conclusion
40 Market Wizard lessons
- there is no holy grail
- find a trading method that fits your personality - O'Shea
- trade within your comfort zone - Clark, Vidich, Taylor
- flexibility is an essential quality for trading success - O'Shea, Mai, Clarke
- the need to adapt - Thorpe, Platt, Balodimas
- don't confuse the concept of winning/losing trades with good/bad trades - Claugus
- do more of what works and less of what doesn't - Clark
- if you are out of sync with the market, trying harder won't help - Clark
- the road to success is paved with mistakes - Dalio
- wait for high conviction trades - Mai, Greenblatt
- trade because of perceived opportunity not out of the desire to make money - Benedict
- the importance of doing nothing - Daly
- how a trade is implemented is more important that the trade idea itself - O'Shea
- trading around the position can be beneficial - Balodimas
- position size can be more important than the entry price - Thorpe
- determining the trade size - Thorpe
- vary market exposure based on opportunity - Claugus
- seek an asymmetric return/risk profile - O'Shea
- beware of trades born of euphoria - Balodimas, Clark
- if you are on the right side of euphoria or panic; lighten up
- staring at the screen all day can be expensive - Clark
- risk control is critical - Ramsey, Platt, Benedict, Woodriff, Clark, Thorpe
- don't try to be 100% right - Vidich
- protective stops need to be consistent with the trade analysis - O'Shea
- monthly loses is good idea if consistent with the strategy - Taylor, Greenblatt
- the power of diversification - Dalio
- correlation can be misleading - Mai, Dalio
- price action in related markets provides trading clues - Benedict, Ramsey
- markets behave differently in different environments - Dalio
- pay attention to market response to news - Platt
- fundamental events might be followed by counter-intuitive price movements - Dalio
- situation characterized by potential for a widely divergent binary outcome might provide buying opportunity for options - Greenblatt, Mai
- a stock can be well-priced even if it has already gone up a lot - Taylor
- don't make trading decisions based when you bought/sold a stock - Vidich
- potential new revenue sources might not be reflected in stock price - Claugus
- value investing works - Greenblatt
- the efficient market hypothesis provides an inaccurate value of how the market really works - Greenblatt
- it is a mistake for a manager to alter investment decisions to please investors - Greenblatt, Taylor
- volatility and risk are not synonymous - Mai
- it is a mistake to select managers based on solely past performance - Greenblatt
References
- https://www.linkedin.com/in/colm-o-shea-28340015a/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_Dalio
- https://www.linkedin.com/in/larry-benedict-023446165/
- https://www.linkedin.com/in/scott-t-ramsey-b3755914/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaffray_Woodriff
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_O._Thorp
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornwall_Capital
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Platt_(financier)
- https://www.linkedin.com/in/steven-clark-0a780155/
- https://moneyweek.com/469315/the-worlds-greatest-investors-4
- https://toptradersreview.com/tom-claugus/
- https://www.linkedin.com/in/joseph-vidich-9b39a944/
- https://www.linkedin.com/in/jimmy-balodimas-7844776/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joel_Greenblatt